When I had to chose a mobile phone to be tagged to the MIO plan contract, I paid about $138 for the Nokia 5300 XpressMusic. Now my impressions of this phone.

Some general info: This model is more of a music edition phone, likely to compete with Sony Ericsson’s Walkman Phone series. Comes with a 1.2 MP (Mega Pixel) Camera, Radio, Micro-SD (trans-flash) hotpluggable, BT (Bluetooth) & IR (InfraReD), 2.5G - GPRS & MMS. The phone is a slide out format (Like some Sony Ericsson’s models), comes with side buttons for music and camera.
Well, since there are already reviews that compared this Nokia model with some Sony Ericsson model (which 5300 didn’t fare too well against), I will compare it with my previous nokia phone I bought…
The N-Gage Classic, which didn’t die too worthy a clause (Nokia Service Center announced it BER-Beyond Economic Repair, likely due to a faulty PCB).
Platform
N-Gage runs on Symbian S60 Edition 1, while 5300 uses S40 Edition 3. Its such a pity, not running Symbian on 5300, mean no application multitasking for me, and lack of a many powerful software, but the only advantage perhaps is better battery life using S40. Yet, the lack of symbian makes a differences for me. Even a low end S60 could be considered a “smartphone” while years later the 5300 on S40 makes it pretty average.
Multimedia
Its disappointing to see 5300 being packaged for music issn’t that impressive. Its on par with n-gage for its radio, and its newer software for music library playing would beat the n-gage in that. But why the lack of support of audio formats? I at least could play OGG using symbian software on n-gage but any java ogg players around? The speakers issnt too good, in my impression the n-gage could play music much louder at a better quality than the 5300.
Ergonomics
Comparing the shape of n-gage to 5300 is like compare apples to oranges, so let me focus more on the 5300. As a slide phone, it has more room for screensize, so 18bit colour 320×240 tft is a nice bonus even when its thickness is not. I see a miniaturisations of certain stuff- the memory card to the current industry small flash format - micro-sd card, smaller earphone/mouthpiece jack, smaller charger jack (means need a different charger!), but why not the smaller micro usb connector as seen in other nokia phones?
Language
Now this’s something that 5300 have, compared to the n-gage made lots of improvement- Chinese support. Also it is now easy to switch to chinese input even if you are using english as your language. The predictive chinese input is very quick and easy to use. 5300 comes with dictionary to translate english into chinese (even though I find the dictionaryformids much more useful on the ngage)
Java/ J2me/ Midlets
I’m happy that 5300 would support much newer/advance midlets (like bluetooth, camera, ir) in supporting MIDP 2.0 and CLDC 1.1 yet I’m very upsetted by its JAR size limit of 1MB. In contract even low end sony erisson phone would support jar size of virtually no limits. Also there issnt a way to send jar files using 5300 using bluetooth to others. My consolation would be at least this phone could read&write to the file system to cover come its lousy jar size limit.
In closing, I would feel Nokia 5300 would be quite sufficient for the average users, but a little below my expectations for me who had seen years older technology phones doing some better jobs that it is now currently.
Recent Comments